Labs in Battle Over New Tax
Clinical labs didn’t get the diagnosis they were hoping for in the Senate Finance Committee’s health care reform framework.
The labs, including big industry players such as Quest Diagnostics and Lab Corp., lobbied hard to convince the Finance panel to scrap the idea of adding co-payments for lab work done for Medicare patients.
Although Finance Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.) did agree to drop the co-payment issue, the panel ended up proposing an annual fee, or tax, on the labs, most likely based on each lab’s revenue. The tax would raise $750 million annually to help pay for the health care bill.
“We’ve already met with the Baucus staff this morning,— Alan Mertz, president of the American Clinical Laboratory Association, said Wednesday. “We have raised our objections with them. We’re launching a grass-roots campaign today.—
That campaign is being branded “Stop the Tax on Clinical Laboratory Services.—
Mertz said his organization and its member labs also are reaching out to bipartisan Senate Finance negotiators to voice their opposition to the proposal, which Mertz said has baffled his industry.
“This came out of left field,— he said. “We had never even heard of such a tax until basically [Tuesday] morning. … We’ve never seen a bill or another Member of Congress propose such a tax.—
Labs aren’t the only medical players upset by the Baucus framework.
AdvaMed, which represents the medical device industry, is also lashing back against a $4 billion annual fee, said the group’s president and CEO, Stephen Ubl.
Ubl said that in addition to that fee, which would be targeted directly at medical devices, his group would also be affected by the financial hit on clinical laboratories. “That’s going to have a residual impact on our members,— Ubl said.
“Candidly, we support many of the elements of the Baucus proposal,— Ubl added. “We are going to make every effort to educate Members about this policy both here and back home.—
A Senate aide close to the health care reform negotiations said that all players in the medical industry will have to pay a price for reform.
“Everyone who benefits from health reform has a responsibility to play a role, including health care providers, individuals and employers,— said the Senate source. “The Finance Committee and the White House struck a deal with the pharmaceutical industry to contribute to reform, and they agreed to contribute $80 billion. A similar deal was struck with the hospital industry. Other industries that are looking at more than 46 million new customers in the newly insured Americans also have a responsibility to contribute.—
But the labs say their industry is being asked to pony up more than its fair share.
“It is a significant and disproportionate impact to our industry,— said Laure Park, vice president of communications and investor relations for Quest Diagnostics.
Charles Silverman, director of government affairs and regulatory policy for Quest, added that the labs already were expecting — and had agreed to take — a hit of $5 billion over 10 years as part of a productivity adjustment that would affect labs’ Medicare reimbursement rates.
“We’re trying to get our message to Members of the Senate Finance Committee, so they understand,— Silverman said. “We’ve done our share, but this goes way beyond. The Senate went looking for dollars and came up with this.—
Park said that Quest, which has 43,000 employees, will be briefing select staff on an “appropriate role for them to play— in the advocacy effort.
“We’re going to be talking to anyone who will listen to us,— Silverman said.
Mertz of the labs’ association added that a tax on medical labs would ultimately increase the costs of all patients’ lab work.
“This tax is going to be passed on to the patient,— he said. “It runs counter to the whole goal of this bill, which is supposed to reduce health care costs.—
He added that it could have a negative impact on preventive care as well.
“The irony is, not only would this raise health care costs, but another key purpose of these bills is to encourage preventive services, early diagnosis, and those preventive services, most of them are lab tests.—