After nearly two years of congressional inquiries that have resulted in an executive privilege claim by President Barack Obama and the first congressional contempt citation of the U.S. attorney general in the nation’s history, there is the potential for a compromise resolution.
The dispute resulted from the Obama administration’s gun-walking program, Operation Fast and Furious, which had been intended to catch Mexican drug cartel members. Agents from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives failed to properly track several thousand firearms that had been purchased by cartel members, and at least two of the weapons were found at the location where U.S. Border Patrol agent Brian Terry was murdered.
After the House held U.S. Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. in contempt for failing to disclose documents in the investigation last year, the Obama administration refused to enforce the citation. The House followed with a lawsuit asking the D.C. District Court to compel Holder to produce the documents.
These events have similar markings to the controversy that occurred toward the end of George W. Bush’s presidency when his administration refused to enforce a contempt resolution issued by the House –– then controlled by the Democrats –– in the U.S. attorneys firing case. A compromise deal occurred only after Bush’s term expired.
The Obama administration argues that D.C. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson should dismiss the case on the basis that federal courts do not have jurisdiction over such executive branch actions. This argument is breathtaking in its scope. If upheld by the D.C. District Court, it would give the president and executive branch near complete freedom from congressional and judicial oversight. The court previously rejected a similar argument made by the Bush administration in 2008. It should do so here.
Recent talks between House Republicans and Obama administration officials to settle the dispute outside the courtroom are an appropriate step toward resolution. Jackson and the Justice Department have signaled some hope for a compromise. Yet a lawyer for the House expressed little “expectation about the outcome” of the talks.
The House attorney has reason to be skeptical. The Obama administration has not been forthcoming in this congressional investigation. The initial Justice Department response to the first inquiries by members of Congress was to deny that its gun-walking program had failed. After 10 months, the department withdrew its initial response and admitted that it had contained “inaccuracies.”
As the House investigated the matter, the department decided to withhold relevant information. In one incident, staff for the House Oversight Committee had to go to the department to look at Fast and Furious documents. Only after arriving did staff members discover that most of the documents were partially — and, in some cases, almost completely — redacted. Congress needs to see the full record to fulfill its investigative function.
Terri Henderson, 6, center, whose mother is El Salvador, attends a rally with members of Congress at Union Station's Columbus Circle to announce the Restore Opportunity, Strengthen, and Improve the Economy (ROSIE) Act on July 29, 2014. The legislation provides incentives for government contractors to pay a living wage and other benefits that would help low-income workers.