Already short one officer, the Federal Election Commission will soon have a dubious distinction: As of April 30, all five of its remaining commissioners will be serving expired terms.
By now President Barack Obama’s failure to fully staff the dysfunctional agency barely even riles government watchdogs. In theory composed of three Republicans and three Democrats, the FEC has been deadlocked for so long that, some argue, the agency could hardly grind to more of a halt.
But the FEC’s growing backlog of work, protracted stalemates and failure to enforce or even explain the rules is taking a toll. At a minimum, political players are increasingly confused about how to reconcile already-complicated election laws with the Supreme Court’s 2010 ruling to deregulate political spending. (The FEC has yet to issue regulations interpreting that ruling.)
At worst, the FEC’s failure to act on even the most blatant violations is sending an “anything goes” signal to political players, who are becoming increasingly brazen about testing what’s allowed. True, most candidates, elected officials and donors simply want to understand the rules and follow them. But a growing number, election lawyers say, see their competitors pushing the envelope and are tempted to follow suit.
“It’s not surprising that a lack of enforcement and clarity is going to lead to people disregarding the law, and that’s what we have,” said Larry Noble, president and CEO of Americans for Campaign Reform. Formerly the FEC’s general counsel, Noble practiced political law at Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher and Flom before taking the helm of the pro-public financing group last year.
The latest example of an FEC stalemate that potentially erodes commission regulations involved a complaint over a robocall in North Carolina’s 10th District race last year, targeting GOP Rep. Patrick T. McHenry. At issue was whether the anonymous call should have included a disclaimer identifying its sponsor.
FEC Chairwoman Ellen Weintraub, a Democrat, argued that under FEC rules the call amounted to a campaign message because it referenced the election, asked why McHenry should be sent “back to Washington” and branded him as “not one of us.” FEC regulations say the rules cover trigger words such as “vote for” and “vote against” as well as messages that in context use phrases that “can have no other reasonable meaning” than to urge a candidate’s election or defeat.
But the FEC sat on the McHenry complaint for six months; it ultimately stalemated and took no action. Now limping along with five members since Democrat Cynthia Bauerly’s departure in January, the FEC must cough up at least four votes in order to act. A frustrated Weintraub put out a “Statement of Reasons,” arguing that the case presented “a clear example of express advocacy” and that “there was no excuse for protracted delay.”
“I’m concerned about the pace of enforcement,” Weintraub said in an interview. “I’m concerned about how we are going to get our work done if it takes six months to resolve a simple case like this.” The FEC now faces “a very large” backlog of more than 60 pending matters, she added, partly because once-routine negotiations have become so contentious.
Rep. Elijah Cummings, D-Md., right, hugs Harold Schaitberger, General President of the International Association of Fire Fighters, after the Congressman spoke at the IAFF's Legislative Conference General Session at the Hyatt Regency on Capitol Hill, March 9, 2015. The day featured addresses by members of Congress and Vice President Joe Biden.