Pressed by President Barack Obama to support more revenue increases, congressional Republicans may relent on the carried interest loophole that tends to benefit wealthy Wall Street investors.
Despite the party’s long-standing resistance to tax hikes — particularly after compromising on the fiscal-cliff deal that allowed rates on higher earners to go up — some GOP sources say Republican members might agree to eliminate carried interest deductions because it would primarily affect wealthy Democratic campaign donors. The likely stiff resistance from New York Sen. Charles E. Schumer and other Senate Democrats would be a bonus. Republicans, sources say, are not motivated to protect contributors who have donated millions to their opponents.
Speaker John A. Boehner “can probably offer a carried interest amendment as one tax increase that is warranted,” said a Republican lobbyist with relationships on both ends of Capitol Hill. “If we are forced into a sequester conference that demands taxes, Democrats can screw their big, rich donors.”
A second Republican lobbyist said agreeing to close the carried interest loophole could serve as a GOP concession on taxes in any of the upcoming fiscal negotiations. The loophole allows investors whose earned income is generated mainly from investments to pay taxes according to the capital gains rate, which is significantly lower than the top rate on earned income most of these individuals would otherwise pay.
A GOP House aide confirmed Friday that carried interest was the most likely place where Republicans would compromise on tax increases — both because it would put top Democrats in a bind and because they believe its impact on the economy would be minimal. Republicans have argued against similar tax increases in the past on the grounds that it would discourage work and investment and harm economic growth.
But Schumer spokesman Brian Fallon disputed the notion that Schumer opposes closing the loophole: “Sen. Schumer supports closing the loophole, has twice voted to do so and will vote for it again the next time it comes up.”
And Don Stewart, a spokesman for Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., rejected the premise that Senate Republicans would support eliminating carried interest. “I don’t know of any Republican effort to raise taxes, though it seems pretty clear that Democrats are eager to further tax their constituents,” he said.
Obama mentioned the issue in a TV interview earlier this month, and his spokesman listed the revenue it would generate as a possible replacement for some of the spending cuts included in the sequester. Michigan Democratic Sen. Carl Levin introduced a bill on the topic and suggested it would be a good vehicle. However, eliminating the loophole is not included in the Senate Democratic bill to replace this year’s sequester cuts.
“If the White House wants this tax hike, why isn’t it in the Senate Democrats’ plan?” asked Boehner spokesman Michael Steel.
But a Senate Democratic aide said Republicans might want to be careful what they wish for. “If Republicans think this is a way to get cute on taxes, the joke will be on them. We will take them up on their offer and pocket the revenue,” the aide said.
Rep. Elijah Cummings, D-Md., right, hugs Harold Schaitberger, General President of the International Association of Fire Fighters, after the Congressman spoke at the IAFF's Legislative Conference General Session at the Hyatt Regency on Capitol Hill, March 9, 2015. The day featured addresses by members of Congress and Vice President Joe Biden.