An Oklahoma judge has ruled that Hobby Lobby Stores is not exempt from a Health and Human Services rule requiring private employers to offer workers birth control at no cost as part of their health insurance plans.
A federal judge in Oklahoma has ruled that a national chain of Christian-owned arts and crafts stores is not exempt from a Health and Human Services rule requiring private employers to offer workers no-cost birth control as part of their health insurance plans.
The Oklahoma case is being closely watched because the plaintiff, Hobby Lobby Stores, is the largest private employer so far to challenge the contraception rule, as well as the first that is not Catholic-owned. The chain employs more than 13,000 full-time employees at 514 stores in 41 states, and its lawsuit was joined by a sister company, Mardel, that operates bookstores employing almost 400 people at 35 stores in seven states.
Both firms are owned and operated by Christians who maintain that their religious liberties are being violated by the rule, which requires employers to cover all Food and Drug Administration-approved contraceptives. Private employers that do not comply with the rule face civil fines of up to $100 per day per employee.
U.S. District Judge Joe Heaton’s ruling, issued Nov. 19, is the second in four days on the question of whether private companies can be exempt from the rule, a provision of the 2010 health care overhaul (PL 111-148, PL 111-152) that is being challenged on religious-liberty grounds in courts around the country.
A federal judge in the District of Columbia ruled Nov. 16 that an Illinois-based Bible publishing company can be exempted because it has a strong claim that the regulation infringes on its owners’ religious freedoms.
Overall, five federal courts have now weighed in. Heaton’s ruling marks the second time that a judge has denied an injunction to a private company challenging the government after a court ruled against a Missouri ceramics company in September. Besides the ruling in the Illinois case, two other judges also have granted injunctions, one to an outdoor power equipment company in Michigan and another to a heating and cooling firm in Colorado.
Heaton, a 2001 appointee of President George W. Bush, said in a 28-page ruling that “the court is not unsympathetic to plaintiffs’ circumstances and recognizes that the [health care law’s] substantial expansion of employer obligations results in concerns and issues not previously confronted by companies or their owners.”
But he said the two companies and their owners had not proved that they warrant the injunction they were seeking against the rule, an outcome that would have prevented the regulation from affecting the two firms. The companies were unsuccessful in convincing the court that the rule infringed either on their First Amendment rights or on their rights under a 1993 statute, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (PL 103-141).
Leaders from military and veterans service organizations joined Sens. Roger Wicker, R-Miss., Kelly Ayotte , R-N.H., and Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., at a press conference to urge the Senate to replace a provision in the budget proposal that cuts retirement benefits for veterans. Wicker, Ayotee, and Graham earlier called for a bipartisan solution to replace the $6.3 billion in cuts to military retiree benefits.
Each year since 1990, CQ Roll Call has reviewed the financial disclosures of all 541 senators, representatives and delegates to determine the 50 richest members of Congress. This year's report, derived from forms covering the calendar year 2012, shows it took a net worth of $6.67 million to crack the exclusive club.