It’s been 14 years since Congress determined that a memorial to President Dwight D. Eisenhower was needed, but the question of how to do right by Ike continues to confound.
An urban park, dreamed up by internationally acclaimed architect Frank Gehry, has yet to win approval from all the federal bodies required to sign off before construction can proceed. Fresh criticism leaves the team of professional staff — experts in presidential history, vast federal construction projects and architecture who work full time from a K Street office on advancing the project — trapped in a design phase that has already taken three and a half years.
“I’m struck by the lack, perhaps, of continuity over the years that we have been presenting,” said retired Brig. Gen. Carl W. Reddel, executive director of the Eisenhower Memorial Commission, outside the door of a Nov. 21 U.S. Commission of Fine Arts meeting, where he had heard another round of complaints about the proposed landscape and design elements.
During the meeting, CFA Commissioner Alex Krieger, a Harvard design professor, assessed the latest concept in terms of a “traditional first-semester architecture exercise.”
“This would fail,” Krieger declared.
Reddel, part of the EMC since its infancy, remains patient. He has read all 21 volumes of Eisenhower’s published papers and he knows nearly as much about the history of memorial construction as he knows about Ike’s legacy. In the case of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, “it took 44 years to complete that memorial,” he reminded reporters, who asked if being sent back to the drawing board might stall progress indefinitely.
After establishing the EMC in 1999, Congress in 2002 authorized it to begin the site selection and design process for establishing a memorial to the 34th president, a five-star World War II general.
At the time, the National Park Service predicted seven years was a reasonable timeline for completion of the Dwight D. Eisenhower Memorial. More than a decade later, no construction permits have been issued for the four-acre site across Independence Avenue from the National Air and Space Museum, flanked to the south by the U.S. Department of Education Lyndon B. Johnson Building.
Under the legal blueprint of the Commemorative Works Act, a law that governs all monuments and memorials to be located on federal land in D.C., the commission needs site approval and design approval from three congressionally authorized commissions — the CFA, the National Capital Memorial Advisory Commission and the National Capital Planning Commission — which have veto authority at each stage. After that approval, and when funds are in place, construction can begin. Upon completion, the commission will be dissolved and responsibility for maintenance and management shifts to the NPS.
By 2006 all three had OK’d the site.
But planners acknowledged from the beginning that filling the space, which consists of two separate parcels of land, would be uniquely challenging. It must be shaped into “a meaningful and functional public gathering place that also unifies the surrounding precinct,” according to design principles established by the NCPC.
After a design competition, the EMC awarded the contract for the memorial to Gehry’s firm, embracing his vision of bringing the heart of the Midwest, Eisenhower’s Abilene, Kan., boyhood home, to the heart of D.C.
Sen. Jeff Flake, R-Ariz., takes a selfie with his cut-out head during the Hoops for Youth 16th annual charity basketball game held at George Washington University's Smith Center, September 8, 2014. The members of Congress team beat the lobbyist team 46-40. Buy photo here.