Some have suggested that Sens. Kelly Ayotte and Rob Portman came out against the Law of the Sea Treaty because of their relationship with Mitt Romneys presidential campaign, but both Senators said they made their decisions independently.
A parallel phenomenon has played out on Capitol Hill since the debt ceiling debacle last summer broke the tensions between conservative Republicans and their more moderate leaders wide open.
Historically, conservatives have a natural distrust of the United Nations, but Democrats were hopeful that industry support would tip the scales in favor of the U.N.-brokered treaty.
The development was a blow to the Obama administration and Pentagon officials, who had argued the treaty would improve national security and enhance U.S. standing in the world. The treaty was concluded in 1982 and has been in force since 1994. The United States is the only major nation that has refused to sign the pact.
Presumptive GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney has yet to comment publicly on the issue this election cycle, but in 2007, a spokesman for his 2008 campaign said that he, like the other Republicans vying for the party’s nomination that year, opposed the treaty.
Some have suggested that Portman and Ayotte came out against the treaty because of their relationship with the Romney campaign. In election years, Congressional Republicans and Democrats typically try to work together to minimize any differences with their respective presidential candidates and play up areas of agreement, aides said.
“The Romney campaign indicated that they were opposed to the treaty but didn’t want to get off message from the economy, so they went through back channels,” said one conservative strategist opposed to the treaty.
A Romney campaign spokesman adamantly denied a role in the developments, saying, “That is false and completely ridiculous.”
Both Ayotte and Portman said they made their decisions independently and have not been in touch with the Romney campaign on the issue.
“Rob announced his opposition after weeks of careful consideration of the treaty and hearing from advocates on both sides of the debate,” a Portman aide said, adding that, to his knowledge, there has been no contact with the Romney campaign on the issue.
Ayotte said that neither Heritage Action nor the Romney campaign played a role in her thinking on the treaty.
“I actually read the Law of the Sea Treaty myself to draw my own conclusion,” Ayotte said. “They do some excellent work at the Heritage Foundation, but I draw my own conclusions.”
Lobbyists at the chamber, the API and NAM dismissed the developments as a minor setback.
“Obviously I never intended to have a vote until after the election because I wanted this issue removed from the political season, but I also made that decision mindful of the fact that I wanted those businesses and the military to have time to work the Hill and make their case up here,” Kerry said in a statement to Roll Call. “It’s breathing space. I think when many senators learn more about this treaty and its supporters, they’re going to be persuaded.”
Dan Holler, a spokesman for Heritage Action, was cautiously optimistic that his side had it in the bag.
“We assume that bad policies never die completely,” he said.
James Jones, communications director for DC Vote, tapes a "DC Constituents Service Day" sign on the wall as he stands with other DC residents outside of Rep. Andy Harris's office on Capitol Hill to protest Harris' actions against D.C.'s marijuana laws on Thursday, July 24, 2014. DC Vote encouraged DC residents to bring their complaints about city services to the Maryland congressman.