Stephen Gass is just a patent attorney, an inventor who came up with a device that can stop a table saw’s spinning electric blade the moment it hits human flesh. That’s not enough to generate much buzz in Washington, D.C.
So Gass came to town this week with a four-fingered firefighter who almost lost his job after a saw blade sliced his hand in half — and three other sympathetic victims of table-saw accidents — to plead the case for tougher saw safety rules with lawmakers and regulators.
For more than a decade, Gass has been trying to sell his table-saw safety mechanism to the nation’s big power-tool companies. When they didn’t bite, he turned to the government for help.
The technology, he said, would save millions of dollars in medical bills paid to cover about 40,000 injuries sustained every year on table saws.
“The table saw is the most dangerous tool in a wood shop or construction site, and it can be made the least dangerous,” said Chris Hackler of Enola, Ark., who lost a finger in an accident in March. “How often do we have a chance to do something like that?”
The invention, sold by a company called SawStop, relies on electrical currents to trigger a brake that stops the spinning saw blade within microseconds of contact with human skin.
In 2003, Gass petitioned the Consumer Product Safety Commission to require all table saws to include technology such as his, which he says can sense the difference between wood and a human finger.
Three years later, the commission voted 2-1 in favor of moving ahead with the new regulation, but its chairman left the agency before it could take the next step in the rulemaking process. The two remaining commissioners were split on the issue, and the rule could not proceed.
At the same time, the Power Tool Institute, which represents the major table- saw manufactures including Ryobi, Black & Decker and Craftsman, hired Ed Krenik, a lobbyist with Bracewell & Giuliani, to help fight the regulation. Since 2007, the institute has paid Krenik $775,000 to work on the saw issue and other matters, according to federal lobbying records.
The industry argues that requiring the use of the technology constitutes a federally mandated monopoly that would more than double the price of the least expensive saws on the market, which sell for less than $100 now. Plus, companies would have to pay a licensing fee to use Gass’ technology, which is protected by more than 60 patents. The companies insist they’ve developed a new safety shield since Gass invented his device, rendering it unnecessary.
The Occupational Safety & Health Administration requires the use of a guard, but carpenters say it’s rarely used in practice. Gass argues that the regulation is toothless when it comes to in-home businesses and private use.
President Barack Obama appointed a new Democratic chairman and two new members of the CPSC in 2009, creating a quorum for the commission to take action and giving Gass another opportunity to get a rule approved.
He hired a lobbyist in March who has thus far charged him $20,000 to contact the CPSC, according to federal records. Gass also teamed up the National Consumers League, the century-old consumer advocacy group, to promote the cause.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, speaks with reporters in the Capitol after a speech on the Senate floor that accused the CIA of searching computers set up for Congressional staff for their research of interrogation programs.