July 31, 2014 SIGN IN | REGISTER

Eventually, the GOP Must Defend Its Budget

I am CR’ed and budgeted out, but it is hard to imagine writing about anything else in a week when the next showdown-that-could-lead-to-a-shutdown is coming to a head, when House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) unveiled his long-term budget vision/road map/blueprint, this time with an official imprimatur that his individual road map lacked, and when the Treasury Department laid out the dates for the debt limit to be reached (and the drop-dead date when extraordinary measures will no longer be available).

In many ways, the most interesting dynamic right now is that surrounding Speaker John Boehner, who has in the past been a first-rate legislator, knows how the legislative process works and knows the risks of a shutdown — to the economy and to his party — are high. The Ohio Republican knows that in the larger context, a deal that results in $33 billion cut from the current fiscal year’s budget is an immense political accomplishment. But he also knows it would be seen as abject surrender by a sizable slice of his caucus and would make it much harder to sell the next compromise, and the one after that, that will be necessary to get by in a political system where Democrats control the Senate and the White House.

It has no doubt crossed Boehner’s mind that he could simply set his sights on crafting an acceptable compromise and finding the votes to pass it, wherever he can find them. That might mean a winning coalition consisting of perhaps three-fifths of his Republicans and two-fifths of the Democrats. That would require Democrats agreeing to save Boehner’s bacon (something that Republicans in the 111th Congress would never, ever have done for then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi). But it would also require Boehner abandoning the sacred principle of his GOP predecessor as Speaker, Dennis Hastert (Ill.) — that policy is to be made by the majority of the majority, in turn enforcing strict party discipline and no input from the minority party.

No easy task, and not made easier by the fact that some of the GOP support for any compromise short of the full $61 billion is contingent on getting at least some of the controversial policy riders attached. The policy riders were part of the Boehner strategy to get broader support for the GOP spending plan, while underscoring his commitment to open up the House. But now, given that these kinds of riders are not a typical element of a continuing resolution, that many are simply non-starters, and that most have little to do with deficit reduction except in symbolic terms, they make the task of reaching a compromise more difficult.

Boehner is smart, tough and savvy — he did not achieve his party’s top leadership post in his second tour in the leadership team without extraordinary diligence and fortitude. I remain skeptical, given the obduracy of his freshmen and the leaders of the Republican Study Committee. They want a showdown, and a shutdown, to prove their bona fides. And a compromise on the Speaker’s part will have his Majority Leader showcasing himself as the tough guy.

comments powered by Disqus

SIGN IN




OR

SUBSCRIBE

Want Roll Call on your doorstep?