How black should the Congressional Black Caucus be?
That might seem like a strange question, but it’s one the CBC has grappled with throughout its 40-year history. White Members of Congress have occasionally tried to join, but the group has remained firm: The CBC is for blacks only.
Many of its members say the concept of an all-black organization devoted to looking out for the needs of black America isn’t yet an antiquated one.
And, they note, other race-based organizations such as the Congressional Hispanic Caucus haven’t altered their membership requirements, either. “I couldn’t go to them and say, ‘Look, I support everything you’re doing so you don’t really need an organization,” says Rep. John Conyers, one of the CBC’s founding members. “I think they would quickly persuade me that their struggles are different from the African-American struggles.”
The Michigan Democrat, like many other CBC members, believes race is still a divisive issue. “I’ve never gotten too excited about this post-racial climate we’re in,” he says.
But the organization is now considering reinstating a membership category, established in 1988 and ended a few years later, that would permit non-blacks to join. CBC Chairman Rep. Emanuel Cleaver says the caucus is split over the issue.
“Some of the members feel good about it, some don’t,” the Missouri Democrat says. “We have not had a vote on it. It’s something that as the chair I want to deal with very cautiously and with great sensitivity.”
In 2007, Rep. Steve Cohen sought membership in the CBC. The Tennessee Democrat’s district is majority black, and the then-freshman described his desire to join as a wish to align himself with the group’s goals and better serve his constituents.
The CBC gave him a polite but firm no. Even though the bloodiest chapters of the civil rights struggle belonged to the previous century and a former CBC member was the president, many members felt that the caucus should remain an all-black organization.
Still, some argue that white members who consistently vote in the interests of black America have just as much a case to be part of the CBC as black members with weaker voting records on African-American issues. Cohen, for example, got a 98 percent rating last Congress from the NAACP. Then-Rep. Artur Davis (D-Ala.), a CBC member at the time, only scored 75 percent.
And some within the caucus see no problem with admitting white members. Rep. John Lewis recalls that in the civil rights movement of the 1950s and ’60s, whites and blacks fought discrimination shoulder to shoulder. Whites are free to join the NAACP, he notes, and the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, the civil rights group he led in the ’60s, was made up of whites and blacks.
“If I could vote, I would say he should be welcome,” Lewis says of Cohen.
In 1988, the group established an associate membership category to which white Members of Congress could belong. Forty-one of them joined, but the caucus ended the practice in the early 1990s.
Former Sen. Scott Brown, R-Mass., candidate for U.S. Senate in New Hampshire, holds his hand over his heart during the singing of the national anthem as he waits to take the stage for his town hall campaign rally with Sen. John McCain at the Pinkerton Academy in Derry, N.H., on Monday, Aug. 18, 2014.