When asked whether the health care debate was yet another example of Baucus giving too much policy ground to Republicans, Senate Finance Subcommittee on Health Care Chairman Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.) said, Theres a bit of that here. You cant argue against trying to get 60 votes, but you can argue against trying to get 60 votes if it begins to lose you votes that you might otherwise have gotten from Democrats.
Rockefeller and other Democrats have bristled at being excluded from the bipartisan Finance talks, as well as at the policy proscriptions the group appears to be considering. Rockefeller has been most outspoken about the potential pitfalls of not creating a public insurance option, the preference of most Democrats, including President Barack Obama. The Baucus-Grassley group has instead been contemplating having a government-sponsored, nonprofit health care cooperative that would compete with private insurers.
Of course, suspicions run high on the Republican side as well. As one senior GOP aide put it: Theres a palatable concern amongst the Conference because of Grassleys track record of putting them in tough positions.
Indeed, many Republicans see the co-op model as just another way of opening the door to government-controlled health care.
Obviously, theres a concern that something might be agreed upon that hasnt been run by the Conference and leadership, said one Republican Senator. Thats why, this Senator said, Republican leaders have cautioned Grassley, Please, dont make any deals without at least talking with the Conference.
However, Republicans have been comforted by the fact that on health care, Baucus and Grassley are not in the room alone, as they have been on previous occasions.
I think having other people there its unlikely that Chuck goes alone on this, said the Republican Senator. The group dynamic its helpful to him and its probably helpful to us, too.
Plus, the senior Senate GOP aide said the enormity of reconfiguring one-sixth of the economy does not appear to be lost on Grassley, who is up for a sixth term next year.
The bottom line is the stakes have never been bigger, the aide said. I think were seeing encouraging signs that [Grassleys] not going to go rogue.
Still, GOP leaders have attempted to sow doubts in Grassleys mind by reminding him repeatedly of his experience with Baucus on the childrens health insurance bill they both championed in 2008. Though the Senate had a veto-proof majority for the measure, the House sustained then-President George W. Bushs rejection of the measure.
Looking to push the same measure again in 2009, Grassley found that Democrats were more interested in passing a different childrens health insurance measure, and he and many other Republicans ended up walking away from the bill that was enacted.
Grassley acknowledged the reminders hes been getting from his leadership as the health care talks proceed but said he knows that the State Childrens Health Insurance Program situation had nothing to do with Baucus commitment to their original agreement.
GOP leaders have made that point, and they made it very clear, Grassley said. But if I thought it was Baucus fault that SCHIP didnt work out, then Id blame him.
Former Sen. Scott Brown, R-Mass., candidate for U.S. Senate in New Hampshire, holds his hand over his heart during the singing of the national anthem as he waits to take the stage for his town hall campaign rally with Sen. John McCain at the Pinkerton Academy in Derry, N.H., on Monday, Aug. 18, 2014.